by
Genghis Khan, (I will use the spelling the author uses on both his and Sube'etei's names. I have seen them spelled three or four different ways) not the greatest conqueror in my eyes. That should be reserved for Timur, but Genghis Khan's descendants ruled the greatest land empire the world has ever seen, thanks in a large part to the actions of Sube'etei The Valiant.
 Within
 the first pages of the book we learn that the Mongol war machine was 
based on the Khitan one. The Khitan or Liao empire ruled half of what 
was to become Genghis's empire in the year 1000 A.D. The Khitans were a 
nomadic people who invaded northern China, and then were assimilated as the later Mongols and Manchus.
 Many
 times I have read that the Mongol way of war and their empire blossomed
 in a sea of nomadic tribes that only Genghis Khan was able to conquer, 
and then let loose on the world. So this part of the book is a 
revelation to me about another nomadic empire only a hundred years before 
the Mongols swept forth.
 The
 book itself is separated into two parts. The first part is on Genghis 
Khans military operations, and the second part is on Sube'etei's. This 
is a book we have been waiting for for a long time. It is a no-nonsense 
strictly military history of the early Mongol conquests.  Before this we
 have had to sift through either hero worship or damnation of the Mongol
 warriors. Did I forget that the book has maps? Twenty four of them to 
be exact. They go from the earliest campaigns of conquering other nomad 
tribes to Sube'etei's later campaigns in Europe.
 The
 book goes into all of the great Mongol victories, but also presents 
their defeats. Again, contrary to many earlier books the Mongols did not
 just spread like the plague across Asia. The were unstoppable under 
good generals and beatable under others.
 Here is an excerpt from the book to show the author's conclusion about the Khwarezm campaign:
 "
 The march on Bokhara has capture the imagination of Western historians 
and commentators like no other Mongol military manoeuvre. Liddell Hart 
held:'Rarely if ever, in the history of war has the principle of 
surprise been so dramatically or completely fufilled.' The manuever 
quite likely surprised and unbalanced Muhammad as well as other military
 leaders, but it was hardly critical for victory: the Mongols were too 
strong. Had they marched directly on Samarkand they would surely also 
have prevailed easily. Temujin (Genghis Khan's given name) gained a quick
 victory because his army was very large and because the the enemy 
fortresses failed to hold out for very long. Muhammad was not a popular 
ruler: by 1210 he had only recently gained control over Transoxiana, and
 could not count on the cities to really support him. Transoxiana itself
 was economically weakened after the recent wars. The political and 
economic weakness of Muhammad probably explains better than the Mongol 
siege capabilities why the cities fell as quickly as they did." 
 The
 author also shows the reality of the Mongol invasions and shows that 
cities that surrendered were not wiped from the map. The death toll has 
always been shown that the Mongols left a veritable wasteland behind 
their armies. This was most certainly not the case.
 At
 the end of the book the author has a chapter called 'Conclusions'. He 
compares the distance between campaigns for Alexander, Timur, Napoleon, 
Genghis Khan, and Sube'etei. They are:
Alexander-  6000 kilometers
Timur - 6000 kilometers
Napoleon- 4000 kilometers
Genghis Khan- 5000 kilometers
Sube'etei- 8000 kilometers
 He continues discussing the Mongol battles, doctrine of war, and siege capabilities, and their terror strategy.
 Appendix 1: Is a breakdown of the Mongol armies' units
 Appendix 2: Is a listing of all of the battles of the Mongols and their Allies from 1191 to 1242 A.D.
 This
 book is a treasure. The closest book I can compare it to would be 
Chandler's 'The Campaigns of Napoleon', and should be on every 
history lover's bookshelf.
Robert
Book: The Mongol Conquests: The military Operations Of Genghis Khan And Sube'etei
Author: Carl Fredrik Sverdrup
Publisher: Helion & Company
Distributor: Casemate Publishers
Robert
Book: The Mongol Conquests: The military Operations Of Genghis Khan And Sube'etei
Author: Carl Fredrik Sverdrup
Publisher: Helion & Company
Distributor: Casemate Publishers
 

 
 
 
Nice... Thanks!!!
ReplyDelete