Mr. Lincoln's War
Army of the Potomac and the Army of the Tennessee
by
Compass Games
This game was originally issued by 3W as two different games. They came in separate boxes. One being Mr. Lincoln's War Army of the Potomac, and the other was Mr. Lincon's War Army of the Tennessee. So, not much different from this Compass Games publication except that the two are now nestled inside one large box. It was 1983 when they were first issued. I can pretty much tell that by the damage my boxes have been dealt, and the tape on the corners, that were suffered during several moves since then. Then again, you are talking about 43 years of use. These games were a contemporary of Victory Games Civil War, seeing as how they were both released the same year. If you look on BoardgameGeek you will not find much written about Mr. Lincoln's War. I am not really sure why that is. I can only surmise that when people have looked at the old version compared to VG's Civil War, they see only the cover and do not look at the book inside. The other game was more glitzy looking, for want of a better term. Well, be that as it may I really liked the older two games. However, I am a great fan of Mark McLaughlin's War & Peace game which supposedly was the template for Mr. Lincoln's War duo. So, that could be why my tastes turned to those two games. Here is what Compass Games has to say about this new double edition:
![]() |
| Courtesy of Compass Games |
"“Let us cross over the river, and rest under the shade of the trees” – Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson before his death.
Mr. Lincoln’s War is a historical game which captures the epic struggle of the American Civil War. From their first major battle at Bull Run in 1861, through the campaigns of Vicksburg, Gettysburg and Atlanta and until the final days at Appomattox in 1865, the armies of the Union and the Confederacy raged across America wreaking havoc and bloodshed on a scale never before or since witnessed in the New World. Reorganized into a single game, The Army of The Tennessee, which dealt with the war in the west, and The Army of the Potomac, which dealt with the war in Virginia, has been combined into one edition.
This box set is organized into two sub-games, “Army of the Tennessee,” which deals with the war in the western theater, and “Army of the Potomac,” which deals with the war in Virginia. Each has four short scenarios that recreate the maneuvers and battles of Shiloh, Gettysburg, Atlanta, and other monumental Civil War contests.
Campaign games enabling the players to fight the war in the West or East are provided with each sub-game. They may be combined to play the Mr. Lincoln’s War grand campaign that simulates the entire Civil War, on both fronts. The rules of the sub-games are identical, except for individual scenario rules, included to better recreate those campaigns. There are minor differences in victory and production rules between the campaign scenarios of the two games, but they are resolved when the sub-games are joined for the grand campaign.
Players may construct their armies as they see fit during campaign games by beginning with volunteer calls and later calling for a draft. Create navies to either smuggle goods through a blockade or close the Southern ports to trade. Can you hold off the Union or seize Richmond and bring about the end of America’s bloodiest conflict?
Product Information:
Complexity: Medium Solitaire: Medium
Time Scale: 1 Turn=1 Month
Map: 1 Hex=12 miles
Unit Scale: One Strength Point=3000 Men
Players: 2-4
Playing Time: 2-6 Hours For Scenarios, 10+ Hours For Campaigns
Game Components:
2 22″x34″ MOUNTED Game Maps
850 1/2″ Die-Cut Counters (4 Sheets)
10 Plus Player Aid Cards
1 Rules Booklet
1 Scenario Booklet
2 Six-Sided Dice
Game Credits:
Designer: Mark McLaughlin"
The game write-ups by Compass Games are always terse and to the point. No flowery language and half a page of words. It kind of reminds me of the old TV show The FBI and its signature line "Just the facts Ma'am". I will try to be as succinct as the above information is.
I have to say that I was never a fan of the game's original maps. The games themselves yes, but definitely not the maps. I will say that these maps are very well setup for a wargame, tons of boxes for bookkeeping etc. These new ones are also works of art. They really do look that good. I do not have a doctorate in cartography, but they appear to be spot on compared to other Civil War maps. They are just better looking than most. They are mounted, and unlike a good number of other mounted maps they go completely flat without having to put weight on them for a day or two.
The Rulebook is in full color and printed in the standard two-column way. The length of the Rulebook is 47 pages. It comes with a fair amount of play examples. The most striking part of it is the size of the type. This is one of those Rulebooks that you can read without your glasses on. That is, if you were not as myopic as I am now. Next comes the Scenarios booklet. This is 23 pages long and is also printed with the same large type. On page 22 is also a full-page with both maps shown together. Inside it you will find numerous battle and campaign scenarios, see below.
The game comes with a plethora of Player Aids. They are all printed on nice thick card stock and are the normal 8 1/2" x 11" size. These are a list of them:
Union Player Aid Card - one-sided
Confederate Player Aid Card
2 - Events Cards - one-sided
2 - grand Campaign Cards - double-sided
2 - War in the East Cards - double-sided
2 - War for the West - double-sided
2 - Unit Characteristics Chart/Terrain Chart - double-sided
2 - Combat Results Tables/Naval Movement etc. - double-sided
The counters are what we will look at next. Now, Compass Games has been wrapping their counter sheets for a bit. This has been a lifesaver with other games because they are so loose on the countersheets that they jump out of them like paratroopers. Alas, this is not the case with these. These four countersheets are a throwback to the old days and using scissors and the possibility of some hand cramping. I wouldn't say it is a bad thing. I mean we have been doing it this way for decades. However, we have been spoiled lately by other games. As mentioned, all of the other recent Compass Games output has not been like this. It is possible that with the 1/2" size it is the only way to manufacture and cut them. Anyway, the counters themselves are very well done. This being a strategic wargame they are mostly either one or two numbers on the units and pictures of vessels, etc. The only writing you really need to read on any of them are on the General counters (we will revisit the Generals later). They are not really hard to read at all. So, their size is really a non-issue.
So, we have absolutely stupendous maps and some very well-done Player's Aids. The size of the counters is simply because of the size of the mounted maps. So, you really cannot fault anyone over that. All in all, the game compares well with the other ones produced by Compass Games, which is a very good group to be included into.
I guess the first thing we should look at in the game is the Generals. The leader values in games is one of the most hotly debated parts of the design. Each designer has his own idea. You know the old adage about opinions, of how effective each leader is/was. In this case, Mr. McLaughlin has chosen to make Grant a '2' and Lee a '3'. I know this is going to cause a lot of head spinning and gnashing of teeth. Some may also get into a huff about Jackson being a '2'. I am sure the designer could write pages about why he chose these numbers. I am also pretty sure that people who do not agree will never be swayed by those pages. I myself am a little confused about a few of the choices. However, I did not design this game, and neither did you. I am, however, confused over the people who post that they will never play a game because they do not agree with a rule or a value of a general. This is your game. You can choose what rules you want to use and what values. Will you possibly break the game? I doubt it. Is it possible that you will unbalance it? Yes, that is quite possible. You may not be able to get anyone to play with your house rules. But again, that is something that you will have to judge. The only thing that I will add is that you should not even think of tweaking with design choices until you have played through a good number of times. At least that is my take on the matter.
The other thing that has to be taken into account with an American Civil War game is the actual audacity of the Union. Most wars before and after this were about small strips of land. Look at a map of the eastern part of the United States. The Union decided to conquer this entire area in 1860. This was a huge far-flung war. The temerity of the Union is pretty amazing. The ability of the agrarian South to be able to fight this war for four years with almost no infrastructure is also amazing. Think and say what you will about the motives of both sides. On both sides of the coin, it was a tremendous undertaking. The only reason I mention this is because the poor designer has to keep all of the above in his mind. The Union has to develop a Navy almost from scratch, and the Confederacy most certainly from nothing. The design must take into account trains and railroads, every bullet, and every cannon. To top it all off you have to have rules for feeding a million or so men long before it was thought possible.
In a game like this, you have such partisan players and their ingrained thoughts that it is almost impossible to gauge if you 'got it right'. The designer might feel so, but hundreds of players do not think so. I for one think that the designer did get it right. Oh, there are plenty of things I could quibble with. However, this is not my design. I was not sent this game to compare it to my idealized thoughts of a Civil War game. I was sent Mr. Lincoln's War to review it as a game or simulation. I also do not compare games to each other, even ones done by the same designer. Games are like the children of the designers. You might not agree with another person's take on a battle or campaign, but they do have a right to it. There is a point where a designer can get things wrong and the map or the order of battle is completely out of whack. That is just from poor studying from that designer. Naturally, those designs should be held accountable. My discussion has been totally geared toward personal images of what did and could happen.
Do the game mechanics work? Yes! Does the game give you a good simulation of the American Civil War and the possibilities for each side? Again, a resounding Yes! Can the game take off like Icarus into flights of fantasy? No, the rules constrain both sides to an effective representation of the conflict. You can try out General Scott's Anaconda Plan, as the Union actually did. As the South you can decided that you want to group your forces in either east or west. Of course, there is always a price to pay for each of your ideas. Attrition is looming behind every grouping of three or more strength points. Please remember that this design was first produced in 1983 and was probably a gleam in the eye of Mr. McLaughlin for a few years before that. So, it has a long pedigree. This is a small list of what the rules take care of:
Attrition
Forced Marching
Railroad Movement
Rail Conversion/Construction
Sources of Supply/ Unit Supply
Morale Recovery
Withdrawal
Flank Attacks
Sieges
Naval Movement
Battery/Naval Gunfire
Washington Garrison
Militia
Partisans
Along with the above, and others, there are some optional rules. These include:
Limited Intelligence
Mines
Mortar Boats
My favorite is the Tactical matrix that can be added to battles. This allows both players to choose six different tactical chits to modify how a battle plays out.
Thank you, Compass Games, for allowing me to take Mr. Lincoln's War for a test spin. It was what I remembered and a whole lot more. Now, I can finally put to rest those two beaten up and mostly made of tape boxes taking up room in my house.
My next review of a Compass Games wargame will be the Designer Signature edition of The Last Gamble designed by Danny S. Parker.
Robert Peterson

















.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
























Follow Us